We are HAPPY to HELP by Phone! Give Us a CALL! 251-928-1720


About Us 

For 46 years, Fantasy Island Toys has been a family-owned business in Downtown Fairhope, Alabama. We take pride in hand-selecting each toy to provide the best quality of play. For generations, we have been one of the South’s most beloved neighborhood toy stores thanks to the continued support of our customers and our community. In 2020, we celebrated our 45th anniversary and we look forward to many more years of celebrating the importance of play!  

Our selection changes daily and our online store only reflects a fraction of the items we have in stock. Give us a call or reach out to us via Facebook or Instagram and one of our toy experts will be happy to help you find just what you need!

For your convenience, we offer:

- Curbside Pickup

- Drive Thru Alley Pickup

- Complimentary Gift Wrapping

We are happy to help you pick out gifts over the phone. Simply call ahead and we will have it wrapped and ready for you when you arrive. Never be late to a birthday party again!

Connect With Us 



Meet our Team

Amanda Calhoun - Co-Owner

Stephanie Bell - Co-Owner

Barbara Bell - Buyer